"Join our free community." Many a community professional may have written that line. A new legal opinion from Europe's top court suggests it may not always be true, or lawful.
On 19 November 2026, an Advocate General at the Court of Justice of the European Union argued that when people hand over personal data that a platform uses commercially, they are paying for the service. If the Court agrees, platforms funded by user data can't call themselves "free". It's a big shift in how the law sees the relationship between platforms and the people who use them, and it has real implications for community work.
What happened
The case is C-643/25, brought by Germany's federal consumer association against Meta. It goes back to 2015, when Facebook's sign-up page said "Facebook is and remains free." The association argued that wasn't true, because users give up their personal data and agree to its commercial use to get access.
German courts initially disagreed. They said "free" only becomes misleading when people pay money. Germany's highest civil court then asked the EU Court of Justice to decide.
Advocate General Laila Medina says data is payment:
• Data has economic value. User data funds the platform through advertising revenue, so handing it over is a form of payment.
• "Free" is off the table when people must provide data that's used commercially. The exception is data used only to run the service or meet legal obligations.
• No need to prove anyone was fooled. Calling a paid service "free" is banned outright under EU consumer law, so the claim is unlawful in itself.
• Platforms can keep the model. They can still offer services in exchange for data. They just can't call them free.
An important caveat: this is an opinion, not a ruling. Advocate General opinions aren't binding, though the Court often follows them.
Why it matters
Most big commercial platforms where communities gather are funded by advertising and data, while marketing themselves as free. This opinion recognises that people using those services pay with their data, and are owed the honesty and protection any customer would expect.
It isn't new thinking. Regulators in Italy and Hungary have already fined Facebook for calling itself free. An EU-wide ruling would turn those national decisions into a standard across the whole bloc.
It also fits a wider pattern. In 2026 alone, the EU Court has ruled that platforms whose algorithms decide what users see may lose their protection from liability for user content, and that YouTube can be liable for videos from creators it partners with commercially. Bit by bit, European law is moving away from the idea of the neutral platform. What platforms do with people's content and data now carries responsibility.
Australia isn't there yet. But with our budding Digital Duty of Care, the direction of travel is similar.
Upsides for community managers and moderators
We think this is mostly good news for our profession. Here's why.
• It recognises what members give. Community professionals have long argued that members contribute real value: their time, knowledge, care and data. The law is starting to agree. That strengthens the case for treating members with respect, not just as metrics.
• Honesty becomes a requirement. Clear, plain-language explanations of how member data is used have always been good practice. Now they're edging towards a legal expectation. That gives community managers more leverage when pushing for transparency inside their organisations.
• Governance gets a seat at the table. When the words on a sign-up page carry legal risk, legal and marketing teams need people who understand the member relationship. That's us. Community guidelines, onboarding and data practices become strategic, not admin.
• Trust becomes a competitive advantage. Communities that are upfront about their model, or run on privacy-respecting or paid infrastructure, can stand out. Being honest is easier to sell when the alternative is legally risky.
• Moderation work gains weight. As platforms are less able to claim "neutral" status, the design and moderation choices that shape a space carry more responsibility. That makes skilled, ethical moderation more valuable, and harder to treat as an afterthought.
• It aligns with our ethics. The ACM Code of Ethics already asks practitioners to act with honesty and transparency toward members. The law is catching up with what good community practice has entailed for years.
We don't necessarily expect platforms, especially the biggest ones, to rush to comply or change their practices. But the precedent matters. It sets a clearer expectation of honesty, and that shift could be a net positive for everyone who builds and cares for communities.
Some caveats
There are some potential downsides too.
• Data as currency. Treating personal data as payment helps consumers, but it can also suggest privacy is something to trade. Many digital rights advocates are wary of that idea.
• Members aren't just customers. A consumer-law lens brings protection, but community is built on belonging, reciprocity and care, not just transactions.
• Words, not practice. Platforms may simply drop the word "free" and carry on as before. Others may push harder towards paywalls, which can shut people out.
An opportunity to reflect
For most communities, especially outside Europe, this opinion doesn't create new legal obligations, and there's no need to react. But it's a good prompt to revisit how you talk about your community and what members give in return to make your community possible.
1. Revisit your language. Where does your community describe itself as "free"? Does that reflect the relationship you have with members?
2. Understand your data flows. Do you know what your community platform and your organisation do with member data? If you can't explain it simply, members can't either.
3. Say it plainly. Consider telling members, in everyday language, what data is collected and why.
4. Check your reach. If your community serves members in Europe, it may be worth a conversation with your legal or compliance team as the case develops. Having EU members doesn't automatically bring you under EU consumer law, and for most communities the EU's data protection law (GDPR) is the more immediate consideration.
5. Start the conversation. If you've wanted to raise better data practices internally, this could be a timely reason to do it.
What's next
The Court of Justice will now deliberate and deliver its judgment at a later date. Once it lands, it will bind courts across the EU. Regulators elsewhere, including in Australia, may borrow its reasoning.
Whatever the outcome, the message for our field is clear: people who build, run and moderate communities are stewards of something valuable, and the law is starting to recognise it. ACM will keep tracking this case and what it means for practitioners.
Reminder: We're not lawyers, and this post isn't legal advice. Always consult legal professionals for legal matters relating to your community. If you need help finding one, we can possibly help - reach out.

